Somewhere in my late-20s, I decided to become a self-styled literary snob. The science fiction and fantasy books of my youth were to be cast aside and purged from my memory. Horror? No time for it. Mysteries? Child’s play. Romance? Oh, please. I would not sully my mind with such tripe.
I did read some great books in those days—books that have stayed with me over the years: Remembrance of Things Past; One Hundred Years of Solitude; For Whom the Bell Tolls; Things Fall Apart. More modern works were okay, too, as long as they were winners of esteemed prizes, or works by daring new authors, or novels that pushed the boundaries of blah, blah, blah. The Adventures of Kavalier and Clay; A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius; Infinite Jest. (Okay, I’m lying about reading that last one. But it’s the kind of thing I would have read.)
There are those who would look at that list and say, “Well, yes. Rather resembles my own library and those are books that should be read, kind sir, so what’s the issue?”
The issue, at least for me, is that when I narrowed my scope of novels to only serious literary fiction, reading began to feel like homework. Much of the joy was sucked away from what was supposed to be a relaxing, leisure time activity. I had set a boundary that didn’t need to be set and clung to it as if some vengeful, literary deity might strike me down if I cozied up with a Particia Cornwell yarn.
That fever was broken several years ago when my brother got me a science fiction book for Christmas. It was written by an author whose online work I had long admired, but whose books—(gasp! Genre fiction!)—I had eschewed. Feeling as though I were committing a cardinal sin, I cracked it open … and was astonished to find that I loved it. It was fun. It was entertaining. It was, dare I say, a joy to read. It felt like a whole new world had been opened up to me. I could read a book that was not considered to be a “weighty tome,” and the consequences would be … nothing. My life would not be adversely affected in any way. All I would reap was a few hours of enjoyment.
When the pandemic shut everything down, my reading kicked into hyperdrive, and I decided to dip my toes into a series about which I had long been curious, but still a little too snobbish to try on for size.
That series was Jack Reacher.
Now let me start out by saying that, to this day, I don’t know if these books are any good. Stephen King swears by them, and they have a massive following. They’ve inspired two Tom Cruise-helmed movies—one okay, one not so much—and a pretty faithful TV adaptation. But does any of that mean they’re good? Again, I don’t know. What I do know is that I adore them. Over the course of a year and a half, I churned through all twenty-four of Lee Child’s Reacher novels. (The books “co-written” by his son, still coming out? I’m gonna pass.) They helped steer me through the dark days of the pandemic, and I will always be thankful that I had Jack Reacher to help me through that time.
And so I thought it might be useful to pinpoint exactly what it is I find so compelling about these books. What is it that has kept me—and millions of others—coming back to these books again and again?
No need to bury the lead here: it’s the title character. When all is said and done, I’m not reading Lee Child novels—I’m reading Jack Reacher novels.
For a character to keep readers coming back time after time, they have to have a hook. And Reacher (as even his mother called him!) has many. He’s big (6’ 5”, 250). He’s tough (never lost a street fight). He has an unshakeable moral code. But for all his tough guy antics, he doesn’t stand in judgment of others. As long as you don’t break his number one rule (“Don’t mess with me.”), you’ll probably be fine.
He’s also refreshingly uncomplicated. In a time when pop culture is still influenced by the rise of conflicted anti-heroes like Tony Soprano and Walter White, Reacher’s life is not one of inner-turmoil. He’s largely at peace. Just be sure to let the man enjoy his cup of coffee.
All of these traits, particularly when taken together, would be enough to provide the reader with the necessary “hook.” But the real draw of Reacher is the fantasy of freedom.
After a lifetime spent in the military—a childhood abroad with a Marine Corps father, seventeen years as an Army cop—Reacher musters out, and for the first time in his life there is no one to tell him what to do, where to go, what to wear, when to eat. It’s liberating, but also confusing. When he inherits a house in book #3 and attempts to settle down with an old flame, the death by a thousand cuts of paying bills, doing housework and living an ordinary life proves to be too much for him. By the end of book #4, he’s back on the road, his only possessions a toothbrush, his passport and some cash.
How many times have we all wished we could do the same? When the mundanity of life and the pressures of our careers and the responsibilities to our families feel overwhelming, who hasn’t fantasized about walking away from it all and roaming free, unshackled from our ties and commitments?
Reacher is a samurai. He’s Caine from “Kung Fu.” He’s Lao Tzu with a penchant for whooping ass.
He’s also Thoreau, breaking away from society and stripping life down to its essential parts. Why carry a suitcase when you can wear the same clothes for a week, buy new ones at a Salvation Army and trash the old ones? Simplify, simplify, simplify! You can feel the influence of the Transcendentalists all over the Reacher books.
Reacher is the engine that keeps these books moving along. As he makes his way around a country he barely knows, experiencing the “every day” with an outsider’s fascination, he comes across dangerous situations and goes toe to toe with pure evil. Are these plotlines always believable? Oh, God no. An early twist in book #1 (which drives the majority of the story) is so far-fetched I almost abandoned the series right there. And are we really to believe he stumbles into these harrowing adventures in every town he visits? I’ve traveled this country pretty extensively and I’ve never been kidnapped after unknowingly holding the door for an FBI agent, or falsely arrested because I fit the description of a murder suspect, or hitched a ride with some folks only to find that one of them is being held prisoner.
But as readers, we don’t care. We want him to be put into ludicrous situations. We want to go along on the journey as he outthinks, outpunches and outromances the bad guys. We want to believe that there is someone out there who’s capable of facing down injustice. We want to spend a few hours pretending that person could be us.
Jack Reacher will never be considered serious literary fiction, nor does it wish to be. More importantly, neither do the readers. We want the fantasy. We want to believe that a part of us is Jack Reacher. We want to believe there’s a version of our lives where the everyday stressors can’t reach us. How could they? We’ve left all that behind. We’re on the open road. Like Reacher, we have no fixed address.